By Vanessa Holburn
For me, one of the best parts about being an author is being away (far, far away!) from my lonely little desk and meeting readers in real life through events at bookshops, libraries and even, rather enjoyably, wine bars! While many writers are natural introverts who fear speaking to a crowd of strangers, I enjoy public speaking, especially when I’m emotionally invested and actively engaged in the topic. And you won’t find anyone more invested in a book than its author!
When I began to promote my latest book ‘Secret Women’ with a local tour my trusty index cards guided me though topics including the ethical considerations I encountered as I wrote, and the patterns I saw emerge as the women told me about the secrets they had kept about their lives, their loves, their work and everything in between. This includes stories from women aged 19 to 90 about surviving the worst types of abuse, enjoying the highs of illicit and experimental affairs, coping with neurodiversity, and body image and mental health challenges, and working in professions that demand discretion and secrecy and generally going against the grain.
When I finish speaking, I open up the room to questions. And over the months I’ve been attending these events these are the topics that come up each and every time – and the answers I give.
How did you find the women?
Since my background is in journalism, I used the same tactics in finding the Secret Women as I do when I search for a case study for a newspaper or magazine article. This meant a lot of social media call outs in dedicated journalist forums as well as more generally posting on my own pages, in public groups and encouraging everyone I knew to share on. I even went old school and posted notices in the local coffee shops, armed with ‘Blu Tak’ and drawing pins.
Typically, I write lifestyle for the nationals and over the years I’ve also gathered a lot of contacts, if any of those were relevant, I approached them. I work on the principle that if you don’t ask, you don’t get and I’m happy to pick up the phone to follow a lead. Understandably, charities will gatekeep any press queries that might put unnecessary or unethical pressure on those that they help, but they might also know individuals that are happy to speak out.
I did a deep dive on so many topics, some that are not represented in the book, looking for leads and contacts. All hail to the internet which more or less gives you access to most things! It certainly gave the algorithm something to contend with, one day I might be looking up terms associated with kink relationships, another the intricacies of religious beliefs.
When women did get in touch, I often didn’t know exactly how they’d reached me, and I didn’t push for that information if it wasn’t forthcoming. This gave my women an added layer of anonymity, because, while I knew their identity and real name, it’s not necessary to know who they are friends with and where they came across my appeal.
For many of the women it was the first time they had spoken to someone about their secret, and it helped perhaps that I was a stranger. After speaking to the women, they might also recommend other women that they knew either within a common field or facing a similar situation.
Was it difficult to cope with what the women had told you?
Despite having spoken to and written about topics such as child loss and domestic abuse in the past, what some of the women told me was upsetting. I have my own life experience as a 56-year-old of course, but I couldn’t help but be moved by what many of the women had experienced, and how they had chosen to share their stories with me.
I felt a deep sense of responsibility to the women I spoke to and wanted to honour their words and trust in me. I gave them editorial control and copy approval because I wanted to make sure that they were happy with what they shared. For some the difference between chatting on the phone or over Zoom and seeing their words written on a page was a shock, and I gave them all the time they needed to work with this and removed anything that they decided they weren’t happy with.
Writing this book has had a lasting impact on me, I think about the women I spoke to often, and wonder how they are getting on. Some I am still in touch with.
Would you ever write a book about men’s secrets?
I was shocked when I was first asked this question, but it was repeated at most of the events I spoke at.
Initially I thought that my answer was ‘no’, that this book represented many of the issues that society has convinced women they should be ashamed of and keep quiet about. Sometimes the silence works in favour of abusers too or maintains a status quo in a world where women’s interests, women’s needs and women’s suffering is often belittled. Consider how medical misogyny and the hushing of women’s pain has meant that for years more money has been spent on researching erectile dysfunction than endometriosis.
I also wondered about the difference between a woman confiding in a female author, and a man speaking to that same author. Would a male writer encourage more men to speak up and offer better representation – or not? That’s an interesting question.
But a deeper reflection made me consider that perhaps toxic masculinity also means that men are silenced by shame and judgement, albeit in different areas of life. Perhaps there was a book in this I thought and writing it would lead to a better understanding of why the patriarchy needs to fall for the sake of both men and women. That’s something for the publisher to consider!
About Vanessa Holburn:
Vanessa Holburn is the author of six non-fiction books including Surviving the Holocaust and Stalin and How to Be an Activist.
Holburn lived in Hong Kong for several years before returning to the UK to focus on her lifestyle writing. As a journalist, she has published articles and features in many of the leading magazines and newspapers in the UK.
